Cabinet refacing vs replacement looks like a simple price question, but the better answer depends on what shape your cabinets are in. Add cabinet refacing vs painting to the mix, and the choice can feel harder, not easier.
At Brushes Over Broome LLC, our team paints cabinets, refinishes frames, and provides custom replacement doors for homes across Binghamton and Broome County. Below, we compare all three options side by side, including when we would steer you away from painting. If your cabinet boxes are solid, our cabinet painting service can update the look without a full remodel.
Key Takeaways
Cabinet Painting, Refacing, and Replacement: What Each One Means
The three terms overlap, so here are plain definitions. Each option solves a different problem, so the right choice depends on your boxes, layout, and budget. Painting keeps your existing doors, drawer fronts, and boxes, giving them a new finish. Refacing removes the doors and drawer fronts, adds new ones, and treats the boxes to match. Replacement removes everything and installs new cabinets, which also lets you change the layout.
We paint cabinets and fit custom replacement doors with refinished frames. Full replacement is a job for a cabinet installer, so we point homeowners to one when replacement is the right call.
Cabinet Refacing vs Painting vs Replacement: Cost and Fit
Cost shapes most of this decision, so start with the numbers. These ranges come from Angi national cost data, not from our quotes. Your price depends on the number of doors, drawers, and boxes.
| Option | Typical Cost Range | When It Fits |
|---|---|---|
| Painting (refinishing) | $2,000 to $4,500 | Solid boxes with a worn or dated finish |
| Refacing | $4,300 to $10,000 | Solid boxes when you want new door styles |
| Replacement | $2,000 to $11,000, plus removal and disposal | Damaged boxes or a layout change |
Note that this is only an estimate.
Notice the overlap. The low end of replacement can cost about the same as refacing, because stock cabinets cost less than custom ones. That is why price alone shouldn’t drive the decision. Ask each contractor to price the same scope, so you compare like with like.
What Refacing Gets You, and What It Does Not
Refacing gives you new doors and drawer fronts, so it changes the style more than paint does. It also takes more labor than painting, according to Angi, because the boxes still need to match the new doors. It does not change your layout or fix how the cabinets work.
Angi also notes that refaced cabinets will still need replacement eventually, since refacing does not extend the life of the boxes. If you like your layout and the boxes are sound, refacing is a fair middle option. Ask any contractor which of these three options they actually offer.
When Cabinet Refacing vs Replacement Favors Replacement
Replacement makes sense when the boxes are the problem. Paint and new doors cannot fix a failing box. Angi lists mold, mildew, crooked doors, and stuck drawer boxes as signs it is time to replace. Replacement also wins when you want a new layout, more storage, or specialty features. Here are the signs to watch for:
Age and material matter too. Angi says cabinets last 20 to 50 years, and those past 20 years are good candidates for replacement. It also advises replacing cabinets made of fiberboard or particle board instead of refinishing them. Angi adds a 50% rule: if refacing would cost more than half of replacement, replacement may be the better choice. You can read that advice in its comparison of refacing and replacing.
When Cabinet Painting Wins for Binghamton Homes
Painting wins when the boxes are solid, and the finish is the only problem. You keep your layout, your storage, and your existing cabinets, and you skip demolition. Painting also opens up a wide range of colors, so you are not stuck with the original look. We take doors and drawer fronts off-site and spray them in our professional paint booth. Our 2,500-square-foot shop is built for cabinet work, and our 40-step process runs from project planning to final inspection.
Painting is not permanent. Angi says professionally painted cabinets should last eight to 10 years, and paint attracts dirt, so you need to clean it and fix damage quickly. That is a fair trade for a lower upfront cost. Angi also found that painting was the most popular refinishing choice among 7,500 customers, at 39%.
Where Our Custom Replacement Doors Fit In
Some cabinets have solid boxes but doors that cannot be saved. In that case, we offer custom replacement doors and refinish the frames. You get new door styles without replacing every box. This works well when the old door style is the main thing you want to change. Our cabinet painting services include this option, and we refinish the doors off site in our paint booth. Our free color consultation helps you choose a finish before work starts.
Four Questions to Ask Before You Choose
Answer these four questions about your own kitchen. Each one matches a point from Angi’s reface or replace comparison.
If you answer yes to all four, painting or refacing is worth a quote. If you answer no to the first one, ask about replacement. Bring photos of your cabinets and note any damage you see, so we can give you a clear answer faster.
What a Free Estimate Covers in Binghamton
A visit from our team shows which option fits your cabinets. We look at the boxes, the doors, and your layout, then explain your choices. You can also start with the free instant estimate on our pricing page. Here is what you can expect:
We serve Binghamton, Vestal, Endicott, Johnson City, and Port Dickinson. We are licensed and insured, and our painters are screened. We are also a Fine Paints of Europe certified painter.
Ready to Compare Your Cabinet Options?
Not sure whether to paint, reface, or replace? A free estimate answers that with your actual cabinets in front of us. We assess the finish, the boxes, and your goals, then tell you which option fits best.
Call Brushes Over Broome LLC at 607-524-5590 or explore our cabinet painting services to schedule your free estimate. If replacement is the better call, we will say so.

